o, last year, the Good Doctor had been coming to visit quite a lot, and of the many things we talked about, one of the things he consistently raved about was this show on the WB, Supernatural. He went on about it so much, I finally tracked it down to watch it. I started reviewing it here, actually.
I watched the first episode and enjoyed it, and several days later, went to watch the second episode, about a Wendigo, and it was just not good. Cheesy, kind of lame, the acting was bad . . . I stopped in the middle and wandered off. A couple of weeks went by, and I had a rough day at work, came home tired and brain dead, made some dinner, and decided I wasn’t up for much more than some stupid TV. So I popped Supernatural back in. The Wendigo was still kind of dumb, but I was pretty brain dead, and not yet ready to sleep, so I watched the third episode.
I ended up staying up all night, watching episodes.
Spoiler Alert! Thar Be Spoilers Ahead!
It turned out there was a pattern to the episodes. It ran in threes. The first one would be kind of “meh”, not bad, the second one would be nothing special, or possibly down-right bad, and then the third one would be
fucking-A creepy. Well, of course, having an over-active imagination that is naturally inclined towards horror shows, I can’t go to bed after watching some fucking-A creepy, so I’d have to stay up to watch another, then another, then another creepy one, and then it would start all over again. Dammit.
The first season was not great. It wasn’t bad, but it wasn’t exactly fantastic TV, either.
But, it was just good enough to get me interested. The stand-out episode of the first season was
Asylum, a take-off of
Silent Hill. The first season didn’t have much of an effects budget to work with, but they really did well with what they had to work with in this episode. The entire sound track is done in B-flat (also known as “the key of creepy”), and there were some really good “gotcha” moments. Also, haunted insane asylum, yo. They did well.
The premise of the first season is that the Winchester brothers, Sam and Dean, are searching for their missing father, while hunting down the “yellow-eyed demon” who killed their mother and set their family on the monster-hunting path. It ends on a cliff-hanger, of course, so I had to get the second season from my dishwasher at work.
The first season rated about a “C” in my book. It wasn’t great, but it wasn’t bad, either. The guys playing the brothers,
Jared Padalecki and
Jenson Ackles are just good enough actors, in the first season, to keep you into their roles. They really excel in their dynamic as brothers — they have some good screen chemistry together, and they’re at their best in the scenes where they’re just being brothers together. Also, they’re both cute as a button, and that really helps when the acting is sucking. I mean, if all else fails, there’s eye candy.
In season two, the show gets a decent effects budget, and they put it to good use. The actors start coming into their own, and the writing gets better. Season two was actually good enough to keep me stuck to the couch for most of a weekend, scarfing popcorn and watching TV. The show wavers between cheesy and creepy and comedy, occasionally all in the same episode, and they do it
well. The plot starts kicking along quite well. The brothers located their father at the end of season one, and he dies in the season 2 premiere. Season two is dedicated to carrying on in their father’s footsteps, hunting the yellow-eyed demon. Along the way, Dean and Sam discover more about Sam’s role in the demon’s apocalyptic plot, and at the end, they finally kill the yellow-eyed demon, but not without paying a steep price. Sam died in an episode, and Dean sold his soul to bring him back to life. If that wasn’t bad enough, they also fuck up while killing the yellow-eyed demon and open a Hell Gate, letting loose a few hundred of Hell’s baddest demons. We end season two unsure if what Dean brought back to life is 100% Sam Winchester, Dean having one year to live before being carted off to Hell, and Armageddon gearing up for the final show-down.
Season three has been fantastic. I’m about to run out of episodes, and I have to say, I’m not amused. Over-all, the show has been pretty damn good. There are moments where the show approaches true greatness, and moments where they’re playing it strictly for laughs, and doing it well. There’s a fairly high cheese-factor, but even that is well-done, and it’s the sort of cheese that’s fun to watch, not the kind that hurts. Heh. One of the stand-out episodes has been season three’s
Mystery Spot, which is a riff on the old movie with Bill Murray,
Groundhog Day. Sam has to live the same day over and over again, each day watching his brother die. It’s funny — particularly some of the scenes where Dean bites it — but at the same time, horrifying. You’re giggling and watching Sam hang on to sanity by his fingernails. By the end of the episode, it’s just . . . awful, watching what Sam turns into without his brother around. All I’m gonna say is you gotta watch out for those sweet, quiet guys like Sam, because when they finally man up, they turn fucking scary.
Over all, Supernatural is rating a solid “A” for me. It’s been a great show, and in season three, the acting, writing, and effects have really gotten good. I’m hooked. The show is like crack, at this point, and I’d reccomend it to anyone. I think one of the reasons why I really enjoy this show is because it reminds me so much of gaming with MrJames as the games master. You win, but no win comes without a serious fucking attached to it. It’s an eerie enough resemblance to a MrJames White Wolf game that I’m tempted to ask him if he’s been moonlighting writing for the show. (That’s nothing but a compliment, MrJames, seriously.)
So, in the end, go forth, locate the show, get some popcorn, and watch it. The first season is a bit of a struggle, and there are some rough moments in season two, but it’s well worth looking past the rough spots to the gem underneath.
ETA: I just finished watching the season finale, and, um, damn. Yep. I am now convinced that MrJames is, at the very least, consulting for the show, because they totally stole his plot for the Giovanni Chronicles. Hey, Jim — remember what Vayle did to Johann? *shudders*
(Photo credit: Supernatural Wallpaper.)